Dinner Menu

Mahaffey’s Pub Menu


  • Grilled Romaine* — Romaine hearts lightly grilled and topped with creamy Caesar and fresh Parmesan. $6.95
  • Iceberg Wedge* — Crispy wedge with Roma tomatoes and cucumber topped with blue cheese or chipotle blue cheese dressing and fresh blue cheese. $6.95
                         * Add to any salad: Chicken Breast – grilled, blackened, jerk or fried — $4


  • Crab Cake Sliders — 3 mini-fried crabcakes on potato rolls. Served w/tartar sauce. $8.95
  • Fish & Chips — Beer-battered and friend to perfection. Served w/fresh-cut fries. $9.95
  • Rosemary Garlic Fries — Fresh-cut potatoes with some serious seasonings. Served with garlic aioli. A house favorite! $4.95
  • Fried Pickle Chips– Served with spicy ranch dipping sauce. $4.95
  • Chips & Dip — Fried Pita bread, with your choice of: Queso ($5.95), Buffalo Chicken ($7.95) or Crab Dip ($9.95)
  • Soft Pretzel — Topped with crab dip. $9.95
  • Jerk Chicken — Strips grilled with Caribbean jerk seasoning served w/spicy jerk ranch dressing. $4.95
  • Chicken Tenders — Plump, moist, delicious! With your choice of dipping sauce. Served with fresh-cut fries. $9.95
  • Wings!!! — The plumpest, meatiest wings in town. Drenched in your choice of flavorful sauces: hot or mild Buffalo, zesty garlic Buffalo, BaltoBuffalo, honey chipotle BBQ, spicy jerk, Old Bay, lemon pepper, chile teriyaki, or Captain Thom’s Thai Monkey or West African Voodoo Juice – Hot!!! $7.95



  • Buffalo Chicken Sandwich — A large, plump breast, cooked to perfection with hot or mild Buffalo sauce and blue cheese crumbles. Served w/blue cheese dressing. $9.95
  • Thai Monkey Chicken Sandwich — Captain Thom’s Famous Sauce. A tangy combo of Thai peppers, wasabi, peanut butter and stout. $9.95
  • Pesto Chicken Sandwich — Topped w/roasted peppers, fresh pesto and provolone. $9.95
  • Carribean Jerk Checken Sandwich — Covered in Caribbean Jerk Seasoning served w/spicy jerk ranch dressing. $9.95


  • Mahaffey’s Classic Burger — 10 ounces of center-cut Angus beef with your favorite toppings. $7.95
  • Black & Blue — Blackened and topped with fresh blue cheese crumbles. $9.95
  • Southwest — Topped with sautéed onions and Swiss and honey chipotle BBQ. $9.95
  • Mushroom & Swiss — Topped with delicious sautéed mushrooms and Swiss. $9.95 


  • Super BLT — Made w/one-half pound of bacon. Served on Texas toast w/fresh-cut fries. $9.95
  • Grilled Cheese — Lots and lots of American cheese topped w/tomato and bacon. Served on Texas toast. Served w/fresh-cut fries. $7.95
  • Turkey Burger — 10 ounces of fresh-ground turkey. Served w/honey chipotle BBQ sauce and fresh-cut fries. $9.95
  • Black Bean Burger — A healthy alternative with black beans, corn, peppers and salsa covered w/sautéed mushrooms and Swiss cheese. $8.95
  • Fish Sandwich — Tender deep-fried cod, on a kaiser roll, served w/tartar sauce and fresh-cut fries. $9.95
For an additional charge, you may add to any sandwich: Raw or Fried Onions, pickles, Cheddar, Swiss, American, Blue Cheese Crumbles, Provolone,  Mushrooms and/or Bacon.  All Sandwiches are served with our fresh cut fries!

Leave a Reply