Dinner Menu

Mahaffey’s Pub Menu


  • Grilled Romaine* — Romaine hearts lightly grilled and topped with creamy Caesar and fresh Parmesan. $6.95
  • Iceberg Wedge* — Crispy wedge with Roma tomatoes and cucumber topped with blue cheese or chipotle blue cheese dressing and fresh blue cheese. $6.95
                         * Add to any salad: Chicken Breast – grilled, blackened, jerk or fried — $4


  • Crab Cake Sliders — 3 mini-fried crabcakes on potato rolls. Served w/tartar sauce. $8.95
  • Fish & Chips — Beer-battered and fried to perfection. Served w/fresh-cut fries. $9.95
  • Rosemary Garlic Fries — Fresh-cut potatoes with some serious seasonings. Served with garlic aioli. A house favorite! $4.95
  • Fried Pickle Chips — Served with spicy ranch dipping sauce. $4.95
  • Chips & Dip — Fried Pita bread, with your choice of: Queso ($5.95), Buffalo Chicken ($7.95) or Crab Dip ($9.95)
  • Soft Pretzel — Topped with crab dip. $9.95
  • Jerk Chicken Strips — Strips grilled with Caribbean jerk seasoning served w/spicy jerk ranch dressing. $4.95
  • Chicken Tenders — Plump, moist, delicious! With your choice of dipping sauce. Served with fresh-cut fries. $9.95
  • Wings!!! — The plumpest, meatiest wings in town. Drenched in your choice of flavorful sauces: hot or mild Buffalo, zesty garlic buffalo, BaltoBuffalo (old bay and buffalo sauce), honey chipotle BBQ, spicy jerk, old bay, chili teriyaki, or Captain Thom’s Thai Monkey or West African Voodoo Juice – Hot!!! $8.95



  • Buffalo Chicken Sandwich — A large, plump breast, cooked to perfection with hot or mild Buffalo sauce and blue cheese crumbles. Served w/blue cheese dressing. $9.95
  • Thai Monkey Chicken Sandwich — Captain Thom’s Famous Sauce. A tangy combo of Thai peppers, wasabi, peanut butter and stout. $9.95
  • Pesto Chicken Sandwich — Topped w/roasted peppers, fresh pesto and provolone. $9.95
  • Caribbean Jerk Chicken Sandwich — Covered in Caribbean Jerk Seasoning served w/spicy jerk ranch dressing. $9.95


  • Mahaffey’s Classic Burger — 10 ounces of center-cut Angus beef with your favorite toppings. $7.95
  • Black & Blue — Blackened and topped with fresh blue cheese crumbles. $9.95
  • Southwest — Topped with sautéed onions and Swiss and honey chipotle BBQ. $9.95
  • Fried Egg Burger — Topped with cheddar cheese, bacon, and a fried egg. $9.95 


  • Super BLT — Made w/one-half pound of bacon. Served on Texas toast w/fresh-cut fries. $9.95
  • Grilled Cheese — Lots and lots of American cheese topped w/tomato and bacon. Served on Texas toast. Served w/fresh-cut fries. $7.95
  • Black Bean Burger — A healthy alternative with black beans, corn, peppers and salsa covered w/sautéed mushrooms and Swiss cheese. $8.95
  • Fish Sandwich — Tender deep-fried cod, on a kaiser roll, served w/tartar sauce and fresh-cut fries. $9.95
  • Cheese Steak or Chicken Cheese Steak — Grilled steak or chicken on a freshly baked 8 inch sub roll. $9.50
For an additional charge, you may add to any sandwich: Raw or Fried Onions, Pickles, Red Hots, Cheddar, American, Blue Cheese Crumbles, Provolone, Mushrooms, Bacon, Fried Egg.  All Sandwiches are served with lettuce, tomato, and our fresh cut fries!

Leave a Reply